Jon Meacham’s Saturday essay in the Wall Street Journal makes an argument about the country that applies almost without translation to our business: America works as a competitive covenant rather than a battlefield. Opponents are not enemies. The system is built to produce partial wins, and the people who accomplish anything are the ones who can accept a partial win and come back for the rest.
He quotes Franklin Roosevelt, who described a contemporary as:
“a sad man because he couldn’t get it all at once. And nobody can.”
And Roosevelt on himself, in 1933:
“I have no expectations of making a hit every time I come to bat. What I seek is the highest possible batting average.”
Ronald Reagan, who quoted that line himself, put the same idea in plainer terms:
“If you got seventy-five or eighty percent of what you were asking for, I say, you take it and fight for the rest later.”
I have been telling my teams a version of this for years. We are trying to get to 80 percent. At 80, we close.
The Last Twenty Percent Is the Most Expensive Thing You Will Ever Buy
Baseball is the right frame, and the numbers are brutal. A hitter who fails seven times out of ten is a star. Get on base four times in ten and you are among the best who have ever played the game. Nobody in the history of the sport has been right most of the time.
In development we behave as though a deal must be won completely or it is a loss. So we negotiate the final stretch as if time were free:
- The last points of a fee split
- The final language on a guaranty
- A $200,000 difference on a purchase price
It is not free, and the arithmetic is not close.
Take a $20 million deal carrying interim debt at 7 percent:
- Ninety days of delay is $350,000.
- Over the same quarter, $15 million of hard costs escalating at 6 percent a year adds another $225,000.
That is $575,000 spent to win an argument worth $200,000, before anyone counts the staff time, the extension fees, the rate lock that expires, or the credit reservation with a hard placed-in-service date at the end of it.
The deal does not care who was right. It only compounds.
What the 80 Percent Is Actually Made Of
Eighty percent is not a feeling. On a development deal it is a short list, and you either have visibility on it or you do not:
- Site control at a price the deal can carry
- A credible zoning and entitlement path, with a timeline you would defend to a lender
- Subsidy identified, not hoped for
- Debt sized at a rate you have stressed, not the rate you would like
- Equity with a named investor and a price range
- Sponsor capacity — the guarantees, the balance sheet, the staff to actually run it
If you can see eighty percent of that list, you close and you fight for the rest later. If you are fighting your way toward fifty, you are not negotiating. You are hoping, on someone else’s clock.
That is the honest Go or No Go test, and it is also the kindest one. A no in January costs a few weeks of predevelopment. The same no in October costs a year, a dead deposit, and the reputation you spend with an agency when you hand a reservation back.
The Headwinds Make the Discipline More Important, Not Less
Everything about this market punishes slow decisions.
- The investor pool is thinner, and equity pricing has drifted down while allocations went up.
- Construction costs are moving on trade policy and labor supply, neither of which is in anybody’s proforma.
- Interest rates have swung more than a hundred basis points inside a single year, which on a typical permanent loan is double-digit changes in proceeds.
- And seller price expectations are still anchored to a market that ended three years ago.
In that environment, a deal held open for an extra two quarters while the parties litigate the last ten percent is not a deal being improved. It is a deal being slowly repriced against everyone at the table.
The correct response to volatility is not to negotiate harder. It is to decide faster, with a clear threshold, and to be willing to walk when the threshold is not met.
The Boogeyman Effect
Here is where the politics parallel really earns its place.
During a campaign, everyone needs an opponent. It is easier to run against a person than to run on a plan, so the other side becomes the reason everything is broken. Then the election ends, and the same people have to sit in the same rooms and do the work anyway.
Our industry does this with troubled properties. A deal stops performing and the campaign begins:
- The syndicator says the sponsor mismanaged it.
- The sponsor says the management company lost control of collections.
- The management company says the budget was never real.
- The agency says everyone should have told them sooner.
Everyone is partially right, which is what makes it so satisfying and so useless.
I have worked enough of these to know how they actually get solved. Somebody puts the real numbers on the table — including the ones that make them look bad — and says what they are willing to put in. Then the next party does the same. Nobody gets everything. The property gets fixed.
The deals that fail are rarely the ones with the worst numbers. They are the ones where nobody was willing to go first.
Candor is not a soft skill in a workout. It is the fastest route to eighty percent, which is the only place a restructuring ever closes.
Taking the Eighty
An election just ended. The campaign language will take a few weeks to fade, and then the people who won and the people who lost will be in the same committee rooms, needing each other to pass anything at all. Watch who makes that turn quickly. Those are the ones who will get something done before the next cycle starts.
The same is true in our business, every single week. The most successful developers I know are not the best negotiators. They are the ones who:
- Know what their eighty percent is before the meeting starts
- Name their three real must-haves instead of eleven preferences
- Are willing to close while the terms are still good rather than wait for terms that never arrive
Get to eighty. Close. Fight for the rest later.
Sean Carpenter is Managing Director of Shamrock Development / SDA, LLC. He has spent 28 years developing, preserving and recapitalizing affordable housing in more than 20 states.



